Chapter 57

As Celine entered the room, no one bothered to acknowledge her presence. She quietly stood at the side, feeling completely out of place amid the lively atmosphere. Lucy finally spoke up. "Celine, you're back." With that, all eyes turned toward Celine in unison. The smile on Sonia's face instantly disappeared and was replaced by a look of disdain. "What are you doing here, Celine?" Lucy chuckled awkwardly. "Mom, since it's your birthday today, I thought it was only right to have Celine come." Sonia looked displeased. "I didn't ask for her. Look at how outstanding Tracy and Carly are! And then there's Celine—just a country bumpkin who doesn't belong here. She's nothing but a disgrace!" Sonia disliked Celine. Carly and Tracy looked exquisite—they had carefully dressed up for today's banquet. They glanced coldly at Celine, then turned to reassure Sonia. "Grandma, since Celine's already here, just let her stay. She's still your granddaughter, after all. You can't just turn her aw