Chapter 190

Jonathan said, "I prepared a gift for her. I was going to give it to her when I got home that night, but by then she had already run away." "I saw Lily's Instagram story. Didn't you organize a birthday party for her? You were there too, so why didn't you give her the present during the day?" Jacob asked. Jonathan pursed his lips, but Jonah quickly spoke up in his place. "There were too many people around. We couldn't find the right time to give it to her. "Jonathan and I had everything planned. We'd celebrate Lily's birthday during the day and Scarlett's at night. But Jonathan was delayed because he had to see the guests off. By the time he got home, it was already late. "He ran into Scarlett just as she was leaving. She said many hurtful things, so there was no reason for us to celebrate her birthday or give her any presents." Jacob frowned. No matter how he looked at it, the way they had arranged things felt unfair to Scarlett. Jonah continued, "We ended up giving all the prese